I used to choose photo subjects based on how interesting they were, not on how interested I was in them: The young playwright with a new play in production; Columbia’s last street sweeper; the large, amiable, and expressive veterinary student. My inability to work myself up to make better pictures or to finish these stories for class felt, and in some ways still feels, like a curse. Whether or not I become a professional photojournalist, I consider my failure to do justice to these stories to be just that, a failure. Mostly I think my intrusion was a waste of my subjects’ time, and to them (in a very empty gesture at this point) I apologize.
I’d like to say I’d do better with those particular subjects now, that I could justify their trust in me, their willingness to let me into the parts of their lives they did allow me to document. But that isn’t necessarily so. What I can do now that I couldn’t do before is be very honest with myself and with my subjects, and in some cases I’d find other subjects that were a better match. The closest analogy I can think of is being faced with the possibility to have a romantic relationship with someone who you know deep down will not work out, no matter that they’re a good person, intelligent, visually attractive, and interesting. No need to give it shot, right? Better to wait for a better match. But class assignments have deadlines, and so I did what I thought I needed to do. It wasn’t the fault of the assignment, the fault was mine, and the remedy was to wake up, which was, and still is everyday, my responsibility alone.
Before (before what? before who? Yes, it was a who, but that’s another story), my heart wasn’t yet awake, nothing set me on fire, and while I didn’t really know this, the way I expressed it was by getting into relationships (photographic and romantic) that I shouldn’t have. And so the failure was mine, but I failed because I didn’t know myself first.
With all this talk of failure and fault, it may seem like I’m being rather hard on myself. To adapt and bastardize Anne Lamott’s metaphor, I am not using the club of truth to bludgeon myself, but to point toward the warm sun breaking through the clouds. I do regret the inconvenience I caused, no matter how slight, and it does sadden me that those subjects, having given access without anything to show for it, may deny the right photographer access in the future. Mostly I rejoice that I can love deeply now – myself, others, humanity, life – and that love makes me honest with myself and others in ways I could never have imagined. I’m profoundly grateful.
While I don’t know quite what possessed Shakespeare to put such wise words into the mouth of a duplicitous windbag like Polonious, I think his advice to his son, at least as I interpret it, is some of the most compassionate I can imagine:
This above all: to thine own self be true,
And it must follow, as the night the day,
Thou canst not then be false to any man.